Computing power is vital in this fast-growing digital world. Dealing with computing needs, you have to make the decision between getting either a Solid State Drive (SSD) or Hard Disk Drive (HDD) for storage. It is important to have a clear vision of storage.
So which of the two is the smart choice, an SSD or HDD?
However, there’s no straight-forward answer to this question; each user has different need and you have to decide based on those requirements, and of course budget. Solid state drives and hard disk drives are alike in their physical specifications, but they store data very uniquely.
Even though the cost of SSDs has been declining, the price per gigabyte advantage is still strongly with HDDs. Yet, if performance and fast boots up is your preference and price is secondary, then SSD is the way to go.
In this guide, I’ll explain to you the comparison of SSD and HDD storage and walk you through the advantages and disadvantage of each to help you decide.
Read also: Must Have Cool Laptop Accessories & Gadgets
What is an SSD?
Solid state drives are an example of newer technology, and progressed quickly, adding more storage capacity each year. SSD can be considered as an oversized and more advanced version of the ordinary USB memory stick. There are no parts to an SSD like a memory stick. Rather, rely on electronic storage and information is stored in microchips.
How SSD Works?
A typical SSD uses NAND-based flash (non-volatile) memory, meaning that data won’t disappear when the computer is turned off. This is, of course, a primary characteristic of any kind of permanent memory. You can read and write to an SSD all day long and the data storage integrity will be maintained for well over more than 200 years.
Moreover, an SSD does not have any mechanical arm to read and write data, it instead works on an embedded processor to perform a number of operations. An embedded processor (controller) is a very important factor in determining the speed of the SSD. It makes decisions related to how to store, retrieve, cache and clean up data can determine the overall speed of the drive.
Today, an SSD is replacing a hard drive with an after-market device and you may be wondering what an SSD looks like. It comes in a standard size of 1.8”, 2.5”, or 3.5” that can fit into the housing and connectors for the same-sized hard drives. The technology is encased inside either a plastic or metal case and looks like a battery and the connector used for these standard sizes is SATA. There are also a smaller SSDs available, called mini-SATA (mSATA) and fit into the mini-PCI Express slot of a laptop.
Advantages of SSD
- It uses less power compared to HDD.
- The boot time is ~10 sec.
- In SSD, fragmentation of drive is not necessary to store data.
- It does not make any noise or vibration.
- SSD supports Disk encryption.
- Faster than HDD, files open much faster in SSD.
- SSD has gained over the physical limitation of HDD.
Disadvantages of SSD
- Expensive than HDD
- High-speed transistors may cause the heat in SSD.
- SSD’s are not willingly available in the market.
- Its data recovery is complex and costly.
What is a HDD?
The hard disk drive is the main and largest data storage hardware device in a computer. An HDD is a non-volatile computer storage device including magnetic disks or platters rotating at high speeds. It is a secondary storage device which is used to store data permanently. It was first introduced by IBM in 1956 and also known as a hard drive.
How HDD Works?
A hard drive fits inside a computer case and is fixedly connected with braces and screws to prevent it from being jarred as it spins. An HDD works on magnetism to store data on a rotating platter. A read/write head floats above the spinning platter reading and writing data and typically it spins at 5,400 to 15,000 RPM (Revolutions per Minute). The faster the platter spins, the faster an HDD can function.
However, most of the hard drives operate on high-speed interfaces using serial SATA or serially attached technology. When the platters revolve, an arm with a read/write head reaches across the platters. This arm writes new data to the platters and reads new data from them.
Moreover, hard drives work on enhanced integrated drive electronics (EIDE) including cables and connectors to the motherboard. All data is stored magnetically, enabling information to be saved when power is shut off.
The main advantage of the hard disk drive is that it is competent in storing a large number of data cheaply. However, the cost per gigabyte is difficult to estimate and it is safe to say that all HDDs are substantially cheaper than SSDs. So if you looking for cheap storage and lots of it, using a standard hard drive is unquestionably the more appealing way to go.
Advantages of HDD
- HDD is readily available in the market.
- It is an inexpensive option for users.
- HDD supports Disk encryption.
- HDD technology has a lot of advanced tools & techniques
- In HDD, data recovery is less complicated, and retrieval of data is possible even from complicated data loss situation.
- HDD comes with enormous storage capacity; the largest one is 10 TB.
Disadvantages of HDD
- It takes time to access the data because of read/write mechanical arms.
- HDDs consume more power to function than SSD drive.
- The hard disk drive uses a fragmentation technique to store data.
- It Makes noises & vibrates when in use, whereas SSD’s are quite as a mouse.
- In HDD, file opening & boot time speed is more as compared to SSD.
SSD Vs HDD Comparison
Now it’s time to have a look at some comparisons and determine which might be best for your individual needs – SSD or HDD? .Those who are looking for top performance can go for SSD & those who want higher storage can opt for HDD. Both the storage devices have their own pros and cons.
|Access Time||Has access time of 5.5 ~8.0 ms||Has Access time of 0.1ms|
|Random I/O Performance||Reach up to 400 io/s||Delivers 6000 io/s|
|Reliability||Failure Rate 2~5 %||Failure Rate 0.5%|
|Energy Savings||Consumes between 6 & 15 watts||Consumes between 2 & 5 Watts|
|CPU Power||Average I/O wait is 7%||Has average wait time of 1 %|
|Input / Output Request Times||Average time is 400 ~ 500 ms||Average Service time 20 ms|
|Backup Rates||20~24 hours||SSD backups 6 hour|
SSD vs. HDD: Storage Capacity
The hard disk drives have the advantage of allowing large terabyte worth of storage. In comparison, SSD is a bit costly than HDD, and the cost increases with the increase of per GB/TB. The storage is available with any base model of HDD is 500 GB capacity whereas for SSD base model is 128 GB. In HDD storage capacity is a necessary criterion to consider when opting to buy an HDD. But, not to overlook the other factors like speed, durability, etc. of the drive.
SSD vs. HDD: Speed
Here, we’re providing you a speed comparison among some popular HDDs and SDDs. let’s have a look-
|HDD||HDD Interface||HDD speed/RPM|
|Seagate BarraCuda||SATA 6Gbps||7,200|
|Toshiba X300||SATA 6Gbps||7,200|
|WD VelociRaptor||SATA 6Gbps||10,000|
|WD Blue Desktop||SATA 6Gbps||54,00|
|Seagate Firecuda Desktop||SATA 6Gbps||7,200|
|SSD||SSD Interface||SSD Speed|
|Samsung 850 Pro||SATA III 6 Gbps||560MB/s read (256GB)550MB/s write (256GB)|
|Crucial MX500||SATA III 6 Gbps||560MB/s read510MB/s write|
|SanDisk Extreme Pro||SATA III 6 Gbps||550MB/s read520MB/s write|
|Transcend SSD370||SATA III 6 Gbps||560MB/s read (256GB)460MB/s write (512GB)|
|SanDisk Extreme II||SATA III 6 Gbps||550MB/s read510MB/s write|
SSD vs HDD: Cost
The SSDs are more expensive, which we have mentioned time again and again. The solid-state drive user would be shelling out more money for 2 TB capacity drive as compared to a hard drive user. If you are developing a system for speed or portability in mind, then SSD is the best solution for you.
SSD vs HDD: Reliability
The hard disk drive remains by far the most reliable storage device. The hard drives nowhere match the performance of SSDs but store the data at an economical price. It’s essential to remember for any storage media device to function correctly. The user needs to ensure a proper environment and working states.
The NAND flash degrades itself after many erasing/writing for SSD drives. Users should remember that for SSD’s temperature range is smaller than hard drives. To maintain longevity and reliability, Solid state drive should be operated in a controlled environment. An SSD has a short number of read & write cycles, and it can last a very long time under regular use.
SSD vs HDD: Lifespan
HDD have moving elements that make them responsive to physical damage. The modern drives include shock-proofing technology “drop” sensors that protect the head & media. The hard drives have a strength level of 5-6 years, depending upon the usage and wear and tear.
The SSD does not have moving parts, the use of flash media drives in a host of latent issues. People assume data stored in these drives will last forever, which is not true. Data stored on a hard drive will diminish and so will the data on SSD drive, but at a faster speed. Laptop & desktop users don’t need to trouble about the lifespan on the drive.
Before selecting an SSD or HDD, consider the following factors:
- For what purpose do you want to use the drive?
- The amount of money you are willing to shell?
- The working conditions of the storage drive?
You can compensate for an option but always remember to have proper back up of data.
Go for hard disk drive if
- You need lots of storage capacity (up to 10TB).
- You just need high storage and does not much care about the speed and performance of the computer.
- You don’t want to spend too much money.
Here are the checklists, if SSD is the right choice for you.
- Performance and speed matter most for you and are ready to pay for that.
- You are ok with limited storage capacity (there are SSD with higher capacity up to 4TB but will cost you too much).
Here is our top choice for you, if you decide whichever to buy.